Why Does He Say “I Don’t Know” When I Ask Why He Cheated?

What “I Don’t Know” May Really Mean
He said “I don’t know” again, didn’t he?
How many times have you asked him why he did it? Ten times? Fifty? More?
And every time, he gives you the same answer. “I don’t know.”
It’s exhausting. Maybe even a little maddening. Because how does someone do something that shatters you so completely and not know why?
Why “I don’t know” feels like a lie
When you’re the one left holding the broken pieces, “I don’t know” can feel like he’s hiding.
Like he’s protecting himself and not caring enough to figure it out. I understand why it feels that way, and your pain makes complete sense.
But I want to gently offer another possibility.
What “I don’t know” may really mean
Sometimes “I don’t know” isn’t avoidance. The real reasons often run much deeper than the surface answer. Old patterns, old wounds, and things he has never looked at, let alone put words to.
So when you ask him why, he may honestly not have the words. Not yet.
That doesn’t make what happened okay. Not even close. It doesn’t erase the hurt or excuse the choices he made. It just means the answer is buried deeper than the one you keep getting.
None of this is a reflection of you
I want to say this clearly: his silence, his confusion, and his inability to explain are not a measure of your worth. You did not cause this. And you deserve to understand what happened.
It doesn’t have to be the end of the conversation
“I don’t know” can feel like a closed door. But it doesn’t have to be the end.
Understanding the “why” is often the first step toward finding clarity, whether you’re deciding to rebuild, to heal on your own, or to figure out what comes next. You don’t have to wait for him to find the words before you start getting answers for yourself.
Ready to get underneath it?
That’s exactly what a Breakthrough Call is for. It’s a private, confidential conversation, just the two (or three) of us, where we gently get underneath it all and find the answers that help you move forward. Inside Marriage After an Affair, this is the work we do together.
You don’t have to keep carrying this alone.
Warmly,Shawn


About Dr. Shawn Haywood
Dr. Shawn Haywood is the founder of Reimagine Love. She is a classically trained therapist, as well as a life and marriage coach, who loves to work with women and couples to help them heal fully after an affair. Over the past 25 years, she has helped thousands of women move from the cycle of disconnect to one of unbreakable love and connection, while healing fully after infidelity, in a fraction of the time of traditional marriage counseling.
Where to NEXT?






Comments